
Leases v licences in property legal agreements — the importance of exclusive possession
4 min readPublished:

A recent court case has underscored the importance of exclusive possession in determining whether an agreement around property creates a lease or a licence.
Here, Charlotte Flanders outlines the key differences between these two types of legal agreements.
What is a lease?
A lease is a legal agreement that grants exclusive possession of a property to a tenant for a defined period of time in exchange for rent. The tenant has certain rights of control over the property during the lease term.
What is a licence?
A licence is a permission granted by a property owner (licensor) to a licensee to occupy a property without conferring exclusive possession. The Licensor retains control over the premises and the licensee’s rights are more limited than in a lease.
Lease v licence — what’s the difference?
1. Exclusive possession
Exclusive possession is the hallmark of a lease. The Tenant has the right to exclude others — including the landlord — from the premises except under specific conditions (i.e., repair clauses or access rights).
A licence doesn’t confer exclusive possession. The property owner may still retain control and enter the premises as agreed in the licence.
2. Transferability
Leases are generally assignable or sublet subject to the terms of the lease itself.
Licences are typically personal to the licensee and can’t be assigned or transferred without the licensor’s consent.
3. Duration and termination
Leases are granted for a specific term (whether long-term or short-term). Termination typically requires formal processes such as notice, by surrender or by the expiration of the term.
Licences are usually more flexible and can be terminated at any time with less formalities.
4. Ownership and control
With a lease, the tenant has greater control over the property and may have the right to make alterations or changes subject to the terms of the lease.
With a licence, the licensor retains the control and the licensee is usually prohibited from making significant alterations.
Court judgment in AP Wireless v On Tower
In AP Wireless II UK Ltd v On Tower UK Ltd, the court considered whether an agreement between the parties was a lease or a licence to occupy.
The key issue at play was whether the agreement granted exclusive possession to the licensee, which would characterise the agreement as a lease.
AP Wireless entered into an agreement with On Tower concerning the installation of telecommunication equipment on land. The agreement allowed On Tower to occupy and use parts of the land for its telecommunication infrastructure.
AP Wireless argued that the agreement was a licence rather than a lease, claiming that it retained control over the land and On Tower only had permission to occupy it for specific purposes.
The Court held that the agreement was a licence and not a lease. The key finding was that On Tower didn’t have exclusive possession of the site and the agreement included provisions that allowed AP Wireless to retain control over the premises (such as the ability to enter and manage the land).
The Court emphasised that the presence of conditions like the right of the licensor to inspect or alter the premises were indicative of a licence, rather than a lease.
Exclusive possession — a key distinguishing factor
This case reaffirmed that exclusive possession is a critical factor in distinguishing between a lease and a licence. If an agreement lacks exclusive possession and allows the property owner to retain control, it’s more likely to be considered a licence.
The decision also highlighted the importance of the parties' intentions and the wording of the agreement in determining the nature of the relationship. The Court focused on the practical realities of the arrangement, not just the labels used by the parties.
This is a classic application of the leading authority Street v Mountford (1985) Ltd, where Kird Templeman famously stated that “you can call it a spade if you like, but if it has four prongs, it is most probably a fork”.
In situations where the occupier doesn’t have exclusive control over the premises, it’s more likely that the agreement will be classified as a licence — even if it’s described otherwise. This distinction has significant legal and commercial implications, especially regarding rights of termination, transferability and the occupier's ability to assert control over the space.
Talk to us
Our commercial property lawyers are experts in drafting and navigating leases and licences to occupy.
Talk to us by giving us a call, sending us an email or completing our contact form below.
Meet the author
Senior Associate
Charlotte Flanders
Charlotte is a Senior Associate in our investment and property management team.
She advises on the full spectrum of commercial real estate matters, including investment acquisitions and disposals, asset management, development projects and landlord and tenant transactions.
Recognised as a 'Key Lawyer' by The Legal 500, Charlotte advises a diverse range of clients, including retailers, institutional pension funds, local authorities and major property companies. Her experience spans strategic acquisitions and disposals, complex asset management matters and large-scale leasing programmes, with particular expertise in the retail, leisure and food & beverage sectors.

We’re here to
Make the difference
Trusted guidance is just a call, email or message away. With hundreds of nationally recognised experts, get in touch today to find out how we can help.
Loading form...
Related insights

How to deliver NEC projects in a volatile market — lessons from our Building Links event
Our latest Building Links event explored early warnings, programmes, project culture and the challenges of managing continual change under NEC.

Brabners caps busy season of growth with real estate partner appointment
We've continued to invest in our real estate services, with David Cole joining our Leeds office as Partner.

Sub-contractor collateral warranties — why they matter when contractors become insolvent

Brabners strengthens national real estate offering with double partner hire & new London office

New VAT relief for social housing land signals the end for ‘golden brick’ transactions
We explain the proposed changes and their significance to those involved in delivering affordable and social housing projects.

The future of regeneration in the UK — key takeaways from UKREiiF
We explore insights from UKREiiF, including how regeneration is accelerating across the UK — from innovative partnerships to sustainable development.





