
Housing law update — County Court rules on variation of possession orders from discretionary to mandatory ground
2 min readPublished:

An important County Court case has considered the variation of a possession order from discretionary to mandatory ground.
The question asked of HHJ Luba KC in Poplar HARCA v Kerr was whether a pre-existing suspended possession order — made on a discretionary ground — could be varied on the application of the landlord to an outright order on a mandatory ground.
The answer was ‘yes’ — HHJ Luba KC found that an application by the Claimant to vary the existing possession order (that hadn’t been discharged) to provide for outright possession on Ground 7A was "in accordance with the rule in Manchester City Council v Finn".
The Defendant argued that such variation wasn’t within the court's jurisdiction (under either Section 9 Housing Act 1988 or a general jurisdiction to vary a possession order) to turn an order made on a discretionary ground into one made on a mandatory ground.
However, Section 9 was found not to be in issue and instead the requirements for the ground would have to be complied with. Here, with regards to Ground 7A, a notice seeking possession and a right to seek a review of that decision were complied with — and so there was a power to vary an extant possession order.
As this is a County Court case, the decision isn’t binding — though it may be persuasive.
Need advice? Find out more about our housing and regeneration services.
Related insights

How to deliver NEC projects in a volatile market — lessons from our Building Links event
Our latest Building Links event explored early warnings, programmes, project culture and the challenges of managing continual change under NEC.

The Building Safety Levy explained — who's affected & what it means for developers
We explore what the Levy is, which developments are in scope, how charges are calculated and the practical steps that developers should take now.

New VAT relief for social housing land signals the end for ‘golden brick’ transactions

STAIRs & Housing Ombudsman changes — what housing associations must do to prepare

‘Manchesterism’ goes national — what the rest of the UK can learn from northern regeneration
As Andy Burnham brings ‘Manchesterism’ into the spotlight, we explore what successful regeneration looks like and how it can create lasting prosperity.

The future of regeneration in the UK — key takeaways from UKREiiF
We explore insights from UKREiiF, including how regeneration is accelerating across the UK — from innovative partnerships to sustainable development.








