Laing O’Rourke v Shepperton Studios — key lessons on payment & pay less notices
We explore what happened in the case, why the notices were treated differently and the key lessons for anyone administering construction contracts.
Housing law update — County Court rules on variation of possession orders from discretionary to mandatory ground
AuthorsClara MoirJosephine Morton
2 min read
An important County Court case has considered the variation of a possession order from discretionary to mandatory ground.
The question asked of HHJ Luba KC in Poplar HARCA v Kerr was whether a pre-existing suspended possession order — made on a discretionary ground — could be varied on the application of the landlord to an outright order on a mandatory ground.
The answer was ‘yes’ — HHJ Luba KC found that an application by the Claimant to vary the existing possession order (that hadn’t been discharged) to provide for outright possession on Ground 7A was "in accordance with the rule in Manchester City Council v Finn".
The Defendant argued that such variation wasn’t within the court's jurisdiction (under either Section 9 Housing Act 1988 or a general jurisdiction to vary a possession order) to turn an order made on a discretionary ground into one made on a mandatory ground.
However, Section 9 was found not to be in issue and instead the requirements for the ground would have to be complied with. Here, with regards to Ground 7A, a notice seeking possession and a right to seek a review of that decision were complied with — and so there was a power to vary an extant possession order.
As this is a County Court case, the decision isn’t binding — though it may be persuasive.
Need advice? Find out more about our housing and regeneration services.
Related insights
Modernising mental health law — key changes under the 2025 Act that social housing providers need to know
We look at the core changes introduced by the Mental Health Act 2025 and outline what they’re likely to mean in practice for social housing providers.
Making Places Work — new study reveals the most improved places in the North of England
Our award-winning regeneration team has launched a new report that uncovers how life and work across the North of England has changed since the millennium.
Brabners secures favourable policy construction judgment for Acasta
Our award-winning litigation team has secured a High Court judgment in favour of Acasta European Insurance Company Limited.
The Crime & Policing Bill — what registered providers of social housing need to be aware of
We examine the Crime and Policing Bill's proposals and outline what RPs need to know to prepare for the changes ahead.
Awaab’s Law — what social landlords must build into their development agreements
We explore how statutory duties introduced by Awaab's Law interact with development agreements and what social landlords need to consider going forward.
Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys — 5 key takeaways for social housing providers (for now)
We explore the implications of Mazur, its unanswered questions and what to watch out for as the appeal progresses.
Southern Housing v Emmanuel — what landlords need to know about forced access
We explore the judgment and what it means for landlords when tenants refuse access for essential safety checks.
Building Links network rounds up the key construction law cases that have shaped the industry in 2025
We provide an overview of key construction law cases from 2025 and explore the practical implications and emerging trends that are shaping the industry.
Awaab’s Law — new requirements for social landlords from October 2025
Social landlords will have greater requirements to address hazards under a phased approach starting in October 2025. Our housing law team shares how to prepare.
Interim payment applications — why you should always ‘pay now, argue later’
Explore the legal and practical implications of the 'pay now, argue later' principle in construction disputes through the landmark case of VMA Services Ltd v Project One London Ltd.
Decent Homes Standard set for reform for social & private rentals
A reformed Decent Homes Standard (DHS) could extend minimum housing standards that landlords must provide for tenants to the private rented sector.
How the Government’s 2025 Spending Review may kickstart a decade of social housing renewal
The UK’s housing sector in 2025 is undergoing major shifts, with Government reforms aiming to boost supply and affordability.
Brabners Building Links event shines a light on health, safety and wellbeing in construction
The construction sector is at a turning point. With tighter regulations, better awareness and clear data, health and safety is being seen as an investment in people and the bottom line.
What is a seating licence? Potential pitfalls for landlords & tenants
While seating licences can provide a flexible and short-term solution, both landlords and tenants must be cautious of their common pitfalls.
Know your boundaries: navigating legal property issues in new developments
Our housing team explore what developers need to know about boundary issues — from spotting problems early to resolving disputes — to keep projects moving and stay legally compliant.
Upcoming Brabners events to tackle key business issues as Lancashire networking groups grow
Events from three of our growing invite-only networking groups will take place between July and September this year in Lancashire.
Making Places Work — Three keys to successful regeneration projects
We explore the economic case for regeneration and outline three key areas that can help to get deals done and accelerate progress.
Artificial Football Pitch Construction — 5 Key Legal Considerations
The key legal considerations for clubs looking to install artificial pitches — from complying with pitch standards to construction contracts and more.
Right to Buy (RTB) leases — be warned about service charges
The Housing Act 1985 leaves significant room for interpretation and discretion in drafting, particularly around lease terms.
Respect Orders — how can housing providers address anti-social behaviour?
The Crime and Policing Bill 2025 is set to introduce new measures and enhanced powers to address ASB — including Respect Orders.
UK construction industry — collaborate on AI or be left behind, leaders say
Our latest Building Links event explored how AI is being used in construction as well as the challenges and misconceptions that come with its use.
Charities warned to seek legal advice before purchasing land following failed £20,000 planning application
There are key charity law requirements and property law considerations to be aware of before a charity purchases land. Our lawyers explore.
Renters’ Rights Bill — key provisions for landlords and tenants
The Renters’ Rights Bill proposes radical change to the housing law landscape and is likely to have a significant impact across both the private and social rented sectors.
Evaluating exit opportunities for Housing Associations in the Local Government Pension Scheme
Our pensions law team explore recent improvements to the LGPS funding level and share guidance for Housing Associations considering exiting the scheme.