Why clear prenup wording matters — lessons from a £26.6m divorce dispute

The recent divorce case of IC v AD shows how unclear pre-nuptial agreement wording can fuel costly, stressful disputes.
Talk to us: 0333 004 4488 | hello@brabners.com | Contact us
2 min read
Sport, Litigation & Disputes, Company News, Reputation Management & Defamation, Brabners Personal

Our lawyers feature in the three-part Disney+ documentary Coleen Rooney: The Real Wagatha Story, available to stream now.
Members of Coleen Rooney’s legal team — led by our Head of Litigation, Paul Lunt — are interviewed extensively in episode three of the new series, which gives an inside look into one of the most significant and contentious libel cases in recent history.
Set in our new Grade A Manchester office in Barbirolli Square, the interviews provide further detail regarding the defence strategy behind the two-year libel case. The team successfully defended Mrs Rooney after she was taken to court by Rebekah Vardy, having claimed that Vardy and her PR agent had been habitually leaking private information about the Rooney family to The Sun newspaper.
The high-profile trial — which assumed the popular #WagathaChristie moniker — ended in May 2022, with the judge ruling in Rooney’s favour. Vardy was subsequently ordered to pay up to £1.5m in legal fees.
Brabners’ original podcast series Rooney v Vardy: The Breakdown is also available to stream on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, having won the Outstanding Marketing Innovation Award at last year’s Legal Innovation Awards.
Paul Lunt said: “Of all the high-profile cases we have handled as a team, Coleen’s was easily one of the most challenging — not only as we were appointed part-way into the process but also in the unparalleled levels of media attention and coverage it generated. By the time the case got to trial, that coverage had become an important factor in the strategy we developed to secure victory both in the High Court and the court of public opinion.
It has been an incredibly rewarding experience to revisit the case for Disney, and I’m pleased that we could provide some fresh insight into what really went on behind the scenes and how the case developed into the national news story we know today.”
Our success in the Wagatha Christie case represented the latest in a series of positive and high-profile instructions for our litigation team, which successfully defended England cricket captain Ben Stokes against charges of affray, as well as spearheading his successful privacy claim against The Sun newspaper.
Coleen Rooney: The Real Wagatha Story premiered on Disney+ on Wednesday 18 October 2023.
If you’re looking for more behind-the-scenes access to the trial, look no further than our award-winning podcast series ‘Rooney v Vardy: The Breakdown’, available now on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

The recent divorce case of IC v AD shows how unclear pre-nuptial agreement wording can fuel costly, stressful disputes.

We've continued to invest in our real estate services, with David Cole joining our Leeds office as Partner.

Our corporate team has supported Happy Days Nurseries' position as the UK's leading nursery group as it continues its expansion in the South of England.

We explain the reforms that could be on the horizon and what employers should be doing now to prepare.

The achievement follows the Foundation's most successful Ball to date, held at Manchester Monastery.

The transaction was supported by our corporate team, led by Partner and Head of Professional Services sector John Spofforth.

From pensions and property to child arrangements, we explore the key considerations for couples separating after a long marriage.

Learn more about the background to the case, why the ruling matters for maternity protections in women’s football and the key lessons for football clubs.

A look at what the MCC’s consultation may mean in practice, potential legal risks and considerations for organisations looking to increase representation.

We've achieved the highest number of ranked individuals in the North West (73) and the joint highest number of practice area rankings in the region (30).

Everton is fighting a compensation ruling that could have implications for potential claims against City, according to Coleen Rooney's lawyer, Paul Lunt.

We explore whether titles could be stripped, the appeals process, what other clubs need to know and importantly, what could happen next.

Our litigation team considers some of the libel law in play around Morgan's pursuit of legal action against the Earl and his book publisher.

A guide to testamentary capacity, common grounds for challenge and the factors that can influence the validity of a Will.

We break down what happens at a Financial Dispute Resolution (FDR) hearing and how can it help separating couples to reach a financial settlement.

Here's how the rapid rise of super shoes is reshaping elite sport — not just in terms of performance but also the regulatory landscape that sits behind it.

We explore how commercial and digital forces are transforming women’s football — and what stakeholders must prioritise to sustain this momentum.

We explain the current proposals around digital Wills and highlight other Will reforms that could be on the horizon.

We explore the Court’s decision and what this evolving interpretation of ‘benefit’ could mean for trust structuring and administration.

With the sports sponsorship landscape evolving rapidly, we explore the key legal considerations for rights holders when negotiating agreements.

We outline the legal protections that may be available if you face a threat to expose personal information such as your sexual orientation.

Our specialist Deal Advisory team supported Wirral-based pharmaceutical packaging business Chester Medical on its acquisition of vitamin and health food manufacturer Power Health Products.

We lay out how the Code will work in practice and what organisations should be wary of when it comes to facilities, participation and verification.

The Supreme Court's decision in Drelle v Servis-Terminal may provide a powerful new recovery option, with insolvency pressure able to be deployed immediately.

Football clubs are facing heightened scrutiny over their commercial partnerships. We explore the risks and steps that they should take to stay compliant.