Skip to main content

0333 004 4488|personal@brabners.com|Online enquiry form

Having been described as both a ‘gladiator’ and ‘smiling assassin’, family lawyer Cara Nuttall is no stranger to precedent-setting cases and looking at ways to rewrite the rules to fit modern families.

Yet such monikers aren't about picking fights. They stem from her conviction that no problem is unsolvable, combined with her rare talent for standing clients’ ground with empathy for everyone in the room.

With the belief that there’s almost always a path forward, Cara strips the fear out of litigation. Pairing unshakeable advocacy with genuine warmth and nerve-calming humour, she offers the steady direction and light-hearted clarity that we all need when navigating life’s defining moments.

Here, Cara (Partner and Head of Family Law) talks candidly about how to be assertive without being aggressive, how a teddy bear charm serves as a daily reminder of her proudest victory and how she helps clients to move past uncertainty and look forward to their next chapter.

 

Rather than success or failure, family law is about real lives in transition. What made you want to dedicate your career to this area?

Family law isn't about 'winning' or 'losing'. Nobody wants to end up in a family dispute. It also isn't about legal point-scoring or resolving an argument just for today — it’s about leaving a situation better than you found it and finding a practical solution that takes a family into their new future.

I knew early on that I wanted to work with people and make a tangible impact. Family law touches every part of a person's life — their home, children, security and future. I love taking a situation that feels completely broken and helping a family to untangle the mess so that they can genuinely move forward.

I also love the variety. My role allows me to meet people from every walk of life. No case or client is the same and every day presents a unique problem to unpick.

 

What have challenging times taught you about supporting people through their toughest chapters?

Over the years, life has taught me that almost anything is fixable. While a legal battle can feel like the end of the world, with time and ingenuity there’s usually a way forward.

That realisation shaped how I support my clients. When you’re in the middle of high-stakes litigation, you can't let the stress crush you — you need somebody in your corner who’s going to keep your spirits up.

Over years of handling complex disputes, I’ve learned that clients need more than just legal skill. They need a genuine connection. Steady direction, paired with warmth and empathy, keeps the pressure from becoming overwhelming. Bringing a bit of lightness isn't about taking the circumstances lightly — it's what helps us to stay grounded, clear-headed and resilient. It’s also about remembering that it won’t always feel as hard as it does today and it’s important to see the bigger picture.

 

When written laws fall behind modern life, how do you find a way forward for a family?

Statute is almost always playing catch-up with modern society. By way of example, the Matrimonial Causes Act — the main law that covers financial settlements — is now more than 50 years old. Similarly, the HFE (Human Fertilisation and Embryology) Act— which covers parenthood through assisted reproductive techniques — is approaching 20 years old. When the written rules are years out of date, you have to be creatively stubborn to find a solution. I simply hate being told that something isn't possible.

I’ve had the privilege of working on several cutting-edge, precedent-setting cases that have allowed the law to better reflect the families it's designed to help. In one landmark surrogacy case, current law prevented my client from being recognised as her child's legal parent. We persuaded the court to 'read down' the interpretation of that law to be compliant with the Human Rights Act, convincing the judge to interpret the law in a way that protected what really mattered: her right to be a mother.  

Afterwards, she gave me a bracelet with a teddy bear charm because, in her eyes, we had made them a family. On tough days, that charm is a quiet reminder of exactly why I do this job.

 

What does being ‘people first, lawyer second’ actually look like in practice?

Being technically brilliant is useless if you can’t adapt to what a human being needs in a high-pressure moment.

During a complex High Court dispute over a child's legal parenthood, we specifically chose a barrister who was exceptionally talented but also deeply warm. While waiting for hours in the court waiting room, she sat with us chatting about dresses and eyelashes. My client said that it felt like a supportive ‘girls’ day out’ and completely removed the terror of going to court. It was a wonderful reminder that technical skill is only half the job — comforting the person behind the case matters just as much.

 

You’ve been called both a ‘smiling assassin’ and a ‘gladiator’ in the courtroom. What inspired these nicknames?

It sounds contradictory but I believe that real strength comes from being assertive without being aggressive. I think that defines my approach perfectly. Hostility and aggression in court will never help your client or find a long-term solution that works for everyone. It only escalates distress and makes the situation worse.

The ‘gladiator’ in me is my relentless drive. When someone says, "No, this can't be done", I respond: ‘let's find a way’. The ‘smiling assassin’ is simply knowing that you can be firm and uncompromising while staying calm, compassionate and empathetic to everyone in the room.

 

When challenges turn family life upside down, how do you help them to take back the reins?

Clients often feel like life is ‘happening’ to them and they just have to react. My job is to step them back from making decisions out of panic. We don't help anyone by acting as an echo chamber — that just feeds stress.

Instead, I help them to lift their eyes to the horizon. I ask: 'What do you want your life and family to look like in five years?'. Once we set the destination, we stop reacting to the past and build a constructive plan for the future. It’s about restoring their agency so that they stop feeling powerless and start writing their next chapter.

Challenges and setbacks can feel like the most important thing in the world. Yet when you look at the bigger picture, they’re often not. After many years of doing this, I’ve seen first-hand that there’s always a light at the end of the tunnel.

 

A family dispute rarely affects just one part of your life. How do you protect the bigger picture?

Family law never touches just one thing. It ripples across your entire world, from your home to your business, taxes and long-term plans, as well as your emotional wellbeing and sense of security. Navigating these challenges takes a complete support system.

That’s why having everything under one roof at Brabners makes the difference. I can wheel my chair across the office to brainstorm with our corporate, property or tax specialists. Those quick, informal chats are where our most creative solutions are born, ensuring that our strategy is completely joined up from day one.

We’re also used to collaborating with external professionals such as barristers, accountants and tax advisors and I often advise my clients to connect with a counsellor, therapist or divorce coach to help look after their emotional wellbeing. 

 

Talk to us

Get in touch with Cara at personal@brabners.com, call us on 0333 004 4488 or fill in our contact form.

Meet the author

Partner, Head of Family

Cara Nuttall

Cara is a Partner and leads our family law team.

She’s highly experienced in children and modern families law and specialises in child abduction, child relocation and surrogacy. As a qualified Children Arbitrator, Cara can adjudicate on a wide range of matters relating to children.

Cara has been continuously ranked in top legal directories for over a decade. She’s recognised for her "forensic and thorough" approach and "Rolls-Royce solicitor" status by Chambers and Partners and is "the go-to person for complex children's work with jurisdictional complications". She's also been spotlighted as a ‘Leading Partner’ in The Legal 500, which states that "the 'one in a million' Cara Nuttall is an expert in domestic and international children matters, as well as fertility and surrogacy law".

Cara Nuttall

We’re here

For every chapter

Whatever your life holds, trusted guidance is just a call, email or message away. Get in touch to find out how we can help.

Loading form...

Send an enquiry