Why clear prenup wording matters — lessons from a £26.6m divorce dispute

The recent divorce case of IC v AD shows how unclear pre-nuptial agreement wording can fuel costly, stressful disputes.
Talk to us: 0333 004 4488 | hello@brabners.com | Contact us
Our award-winning non-court dispute resolution solicitors help you to find the right way forward for your family law issue — whether arbitration, mediation or collaborative law.
In recent years, NCDR has become increasingly popular and efficient way to resolve family issues in respect of financial matters and arrangements for children. Often quicker and more cost-effective than traditional court options, it can provide a bespoke way to achieve the right result — even in complex family law disputes.
NCDR can be used for most types of financial settlement disputes, including issues like interim maintenance, legal services funding and the overall division of assets, as well as most common children issues, such as with whom the children will live, what time they will spend with the other parent and disputes over holidays and education.
Our trusted and award-winning family law team is recognised in The Times Best Law Firms and has a wealth of experience as both participant and tribunal in using NCDR to ensure the best route to resolution for any family law issue.
Talk to us by giving us a call on 0333 004 4488, sending us an email at family@brabners.com or completing our contact form below.
“I’m so grateful to Brabners — particularly Danielle Hutchinson and Caitlyn Oaten — for their outstanding support during a long and complex financial case. From the FDR hearing right through to the final settlement and property transfer, they carried out everything with professionalism, empathy and precision.”
Client feedback
“Brabners is a very established international family firm dripping with experience, knowledge and dedication. The family team is available to meet every client's needs across the board in children and financial cases. They're leaders in the field of international, cross-jurisdictional, and complex cases.”
Client feedback, Legal 500, 2027
“Leanne [Instrall]’s support and advice was always greatly appreciated. I always particularly liked how she put the needs of the children at the fore of her advice. The peace of mind this order has given me is invaluable.”
Client feedback
“Extremely competent, with very high-quality individuals leading and making up the team.”
Client feedback, Legal 500, 2027

While our experts can travel nationally for the purpose of adjudicating a dispute, our fabulous, award-winning offices — conveniently located in Liverpool, Manchester, London, Leeds and Lancashire — provide modern, comfortable and completely private surroundings.
Whether you’re looking for an arbitrator or private financial dispute resolution (FDR) Judge to adjudicate your case, or want to be guided through the available options to choose the right one for you, as early adopters of the NCDR model our experts are perfectly placed to advise.
Backed-up by the capabilities of our full-service legal offering — including in privacy, defamation and reputation management — we will carefully guide you through each step of the dispute resolution process.
Find out more about the different types of NCDR and how we can help below.

Family arbitration in England and Wales is a form of NCDR where you and your ex-partner appoint a qualified family arbitrator to resolve disputes relating to family matters. It can offer a faster and more confidential alternative to traditional court proceedings.
It can be used in most kinds of financial and children disputes. Our Partner Helen Marriott was the first family solicitor in Liverpool to qualify as an arbitrator and is experienced in complex financial cases. Partner Cara Nuttall is qualified to arbitrate on children matters, including child arrangements, relocation, schooling, religion, holidays and a child’s name.
An arbitrator is a highly trained individual who has the power to make binding decisions and will have no connection to your case. Often, arbitrators are experienced family law solicitors, barristers or retired judges. They will hear both parties’ positions before imposing a decision (like a judge).
Parties that sign up to arbitration agree to be bound by the decision of the arbitrator. A decision can only be challenged in limited circumstances. Once the decision (known as the award) is made, it’s translated into a court order, which is usually submitted to the court as an administrative exercise without the need to attend court at all. If you’re involved in mediation, you'll usually still be represented by solicitors and/or a barrister within the arbitration process.
With extensive litigation and NCDR experience, our team can advise and represent you throughout the process, from deciding whether arbitration is right for you to preparing your case and identifying the right arbitrator.

Mediation involves a couple meeting with a specially trained family law mediator to discuss their dispute. The mediator is independent and doesn’t provide legal advice but assists both parties to reach an agreement.
Once an agreement is reached, a consent order is drafted to reflect its terms and turn it into a legally binding and enforceable outcome once approved by the court. While solicitors don’t usually attend mediation sessions, taking legal advice and understanding your legal position is a crucial part of the process.
We can ensure that you have the right advice to make fully informed decisions. Once you've reached an agreement, we can draft the court order and help you to obtain the court’s approval.
Often used in more complex disputes, hybrid mediation usually sees solicitors attend mediation sessions to provide advice and participate in discussions and negotiations.
Our expert family lawyers can help you to prepare for your sessions and make sure that you have the best framework in place.

Collaborative law is a process that involves specially trained collaborative solicitors who help to guide the parties to an agreed outcome over a series of meetings, often involving other relevant professionals such as accountants and tax advisors.
Each party has their own solicitor who advises and assists throughout. Those participating in the process sign up to a code of conduct, agreeing that they won’t resort to court unless the collaborative process fails.
Once an agreement is reached, the lawyers will draft it in the form of a court order, which is then submitted to the court for approval.
Our Partner Leanne Instrall is a trained collaborative lawyer who can advise and support you throughout the process.

Private FDR hearings can be used when you're within the court process or have decided to use NCDR but still need more input than mediation or collaborative processes offer.
A private FDR mirrors the FDR process within the court timetable. Someone acting as a judge will consider both parties’ positions before offering guidance on the appropriate parameters for settlement and what they believe would happen if matters go to court.
Like other forms of NCDR, a private FDR is ‘without prejudice’, meaning that you can’t later be held to proposals you make to try to reach a settlement if an agreement isn’t reached. Unlike arbitration, a private FDR can't impose an outcome on the parties.
ENEs are similar to FDRs, with the evaluator considering the papers and facts before giving an opinion on what they consider the outcome should be. A standalone review, an ENE is essentially the ‘indication’ that would be provided at an FDR hearing. They can be used in either financial or children matters.
Our award-winning family law team has extensive experience in complex financial disputes and offers private FDR ‘judges’ to suit different cases and budgets. We can also prepare and represent you at a private FDR, helping you to work towards an outcome that protects your family’s future.


We sat down with Danielle Hutchison from our family law team to answer some of the common questions they get asked about the mediation process.

The recent divorce case of IC v AD shows how unclear pre-nuptial agreement wording can fuel costly, stressful disputes.

From pensions and property to child arrangements, we explore the key considerations for couples separating after a long marriage.

We break down what happens at a Financial Dispute Resolution (FDR) hearing and how can it help separating couples to reach a financial settlement.

We explore what the decision means in practice for parties, witnesses and experts based overseas and outline when evidence can be given remotely.

We explore the potential impact of the Government's consultation and outline the practical steps that you can take to prepare.

We delve into the new data, what it tells us about the ‘modern family’ and the steps that cohabiting couples should take to protect their rights.

We outline how an overseas marriage is treated under English and Welsh law for anyone considering divorce.

We explore how adultery and other forms of misconduct fit into the current divorce framework and when behaviour affects the financial settlement.

We explore how the courts approach trusts on divorce and outline the key considerations for dealing with them after separation.

We explore how decisions around schools are made, the processes available to help parents to reach agreement and the court’s approach when they can't.

We explore the process of valuing a business and reaching a financial settlement upon divorce or dissolution.

We explore how the courts approach parental contributions in divorce and the practical steps families may need to consider.

We explore how pensions are treated in divorce, from entitlement and valuation to division options.

We set out everything you need to know about financial orders — how they work, the different types and more.

We explain how and when a marriage can be annulled as well as how to know if a marriage is void or voidable.

We explore how financial remedy proceedings work, what the court takes into account and the steps involved.

We share some top tips to help families to co‑parent amicably and organise child contact arrangements during the festive period.

We're thrilled to have been commended in three separate categories in The Times Best Law Firms 2026.

For Good Divorce Week, we explore how emotional support and legal guidance work together to reduce conflict and uncertainty.

We explore the biological realities of menopause and the impact that it can have on divorce settlements and financial claims.

The importance of a Pension Sharing Order, the process for implementing one and the remedies available if one party fails to engage in that process.

NDAs are becoming more prevalent in divorce proceedings, especially for high-profile individuals or where sensitive information is concerned — but do you need one?

International divorce cases are highly complex and the choice of jurisdiction can make a significant difference to financial outcomes.

January and September are the most ‘popular’ months to begin divorce proceedings — we look at why and top tips for couples thinking of separation.

Divorce isn't an option until after 12 months — but alternatives like annulment, judicial separation and separation agreements are available.

Our independence allows us to be objective, principled and provide a service with heart and personality.
We’re on a mission to make the difference for our clients, people and communities. Proudly anchored in the North since 1815, we serve all of England and Wales.
Loading form...