PREM Rugby’s £34m black hole — is financial sustainability in sight?

A year on from our last review, we to take a fresh look at the state of rugby’s finances to see what progress has been made and which challenges remain.
We make the difference. Talk to us: 0333 004 4488 | hello@brabners.com
AuthorsWilliam Hardwick

The Premier League has taken a major step toward reshaping its financial regulation framework, voting to replace the long‑standing Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) with two new systems — the Squad Cost Ratio (SCR) and the Sustainability and Systematic Resilience Proposal (SSR) — from the 2026/27 season.
With exactly 14 of the 20 football clubs voting in favour — the minimum required for any rule change — this shift reshapes spending controls, redefines sustainability assessments and strengthens club accountability. Here, Will Hardwick explores what the new rules mean, how they differ from PSR and what clubs can expect next.
From next season, Premier League clubs will be allowed to spend a maximum of 85% of their revenue on squad costs on a seasonal basis. Those squad costs include head coach wages, player wages, amortised transfers and agents’ fees. Staff outside of the playing squad — such as administrative or commercial personnel — are excluded, as are assistant coaches and other coaching team members. Income relating to women’s teams and youth academies are included in the calculation but costs aren’t, providing clubs with freedom to invest in these areas.
There’s a slight catch, however. For teams competing in UEFA competitions, the limit will be 70% of revenue in line with UEFA’s rules.
The introduction of SCR brings a degree of alignment with UEFA’s financial sustainability rules. One key difference is that the Premier League’s SCR will run on a seasonal basis rather than UEFA’s calendar-year basis.
The SCR calculation will be based solely on clubs’ football revenues. It switches the focus from overall losses to on-pitch spending relative to income. Under PSR, clubs were previously allowed to lose up to £105m over three seasons with the emphasis being on profit and loss and ensuring that clubs didn’t spend beyond their means.
The Premier League have said that it “enables more timely enforcement and encourages clubs to manage their finances responsibly in real time, rather than relying on longer-term financial balancing”.
Yes — clubs can exceed this threshold by up to 30%. The 85% is known as the Green Threshold, while 115% is the Red Threshold.
Compliance monitoring will take place in-season and be tested on 1 March.
If a club’s SCR exceeds the Green Threshold in both the Compliance Test and Accounts Confirmation Test, it’ll face financial sanctions in the form of levies (but no sporting sanctions). The fine is calculated by multiplying the percentage overspend above 85% by the overspend figure. For example, if a club overspent by £2m and its ratio was 90%, the calculation would be 2,000,000 x 0.05 = £100,000.
If a club exceeds the Red Threshold, it’ll face a sporting sanction in the form of a points deduction. This is a fixed six-point deduction that increases by one point for every £6.5m spent over the threshold.
These are a set of tests designed to “improve a club’s sustainability and ‘investability’ over the short-, medium- and long-term”.
The tests are:
Each tests take place on 7 July each year. Newly promoted clubs will be assessed on the Liquidity and Positive Equity Tests on October 31.
The Premier League has also closed a loophole that allowed clubs to sell assets to owner-linked companies to artificially boost revenues and remain compliant with PSR rules. Chelsea F.C.’s sale of two hotels and its women’s teams to sister and parent companies are among the most well-known examples.
Our nationally and internationally recognised sports law team works with elite clubs, national governing bodies, international federations and major sports agencies across the UK and beyond. With deep expertise in the regulatory landscape — including financial rules, governance, commercial matters and dispute resolution — we’re well placed to support you across the full range of issues facing the sector.
To explore how our team can help you to navigate a fast‑evolving industry, call 0333 004 4488, email hello@brabners.com or complete our contact form below.

Loading form...

A year on from our last review, we to take a fresh look at the state of rugby’s finances to see what progress has been made and which challenges remain.

We break down the key stages of a footballer’s career and outline how the right guidance safeguards their wealth and long‑term future.

We explore the key findings from the study and outline what they mean for clubs, governing bodies and others responsible for player welfare.

We explore how athletes like Cole Palmer and Luke Littler are using trade marks and outline the legal standards that they must meet.

AI is enhancing performance and even scouting future talent in elite sport. Sports technology and data are key to success, but come with legal risks.

We explore how athlete expression, public scrutiny and the IOC’s rulebook collided on one of the world’s biggest sporting stages.

We explore the consultation background, the regulatory concerns driving it and what it could mean for clubs with existing or future sponsorship deals.

We discuss the mounting dangers of AI-powered cybercrime across the world of sport with David Andrew — the Founder and Managing Partner of Tiaki.

We explore how structural, environmental and organisational shifts are shaping the 2026 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games.

We examine the consequences of Palou’s defection and the wider lessons for businesses negotiating contracts with athletes or other high‑value individuals.

We explore how World Rugby’s newest reforms are reshaping the sport and what they mean for clubs and governing bodies ahead of the 2026 Six Nations.

We’re delighted to announce the opening of a new office in London, marking a major milestone at the end of a year defined by strong financial performance.

2025 could well be remembered as the ‘end of the beginning’ for The Hundred.

We explore what’s known and emerging about GLP‑1 drugs like Ozempic and Mounjaro and what athletes need to consider as interest and scrutiny grow.

We explore the new immigration changes including higher salary thresholds, stricter qualification levels and limited relief under the TSL.

We explore how the Employment Rights Bill reshapes union access, strike rules and workplace protections for sport organisations.

We explore how women’s cricket is evolving and what that means for the sport’s future on and off the field.

We explore how AI is influencing football on and off the pitch, highlighting the real-world examples of its impact and the risks that come with it.

We explore the legal context of the proposed ban, its potential compliance challenges and the likely impact on sports governance.

We're thrilled to have been commended in three separate categories in The Times Best Law Firms 2026.

We explore some of the legal considerations for clubs in ‘hiving out’ their women’s team from existing corporate structures.

For the first time in history, both men and women compete side-by-side for the title of World Boxing Champion in ten weight classes each.

We explore how The Hundred's landmark £520m investment could support the regeneration of historic grounds that help local communities to thrive.

At the State of Play Conference 2025, leading voices from across the sport sector shared their insights on the topic of sports technology.

Sport and entertainment are becoming increasingly intertwined, with sports and leagues forced to innovate to keep pace with trends.