Skip to main content

0333 004 4488|hello@brabners.com|Online enquiry form

Tax Disputes & Investigations

Our legal experts deal with all types of civil and criminal tax disputes and investigations.

Anyone can find themselves in dispute with HMRC in respect of their tax affairs. Such disputes can be technically and legally complex, requiring considerable resource to resolve.

  • Leading lawyers recognised by Legal 500.
  • Experience in some of the largest and most complex tax disputes.
  • Expertise in civil and criminal HMRC investigations.

Let’s talk

Get in touch to find out how we can help.

Recognised as a top-tier firm in the Legal 500

Winner of Legal 500 Northern Powerhouse Awards 2026 for Dispute Resolution, Firm of the Year written in gold and white on a dark background.
Legal 500 Top Tier Firm
Legal 500 Hall of Fame
Legal 500 Next Generation Partner
Legal 500 Leading Associate
Dark blue rounded-square badge with the Legal500 branding, a white pill label RECOMMENDED LAWYER, and UNITED KINGDOM 2027 in white text.
Winner of Legal 500 Northern Powerhouse Awards 2026 for Dispute Resolution, Firm of the Year written in gold and white on a dark background.
Legal 500 Top Tier Firm
Legal 500 Hall of Fame
Legal 500 Next Generation Partner
Legal 500 Leading Associate
Dark blue rounded-square badge with the Legal500 branding, a white pill label RECOMMENDED LAWYER, and UNITED KINGDOM 2027 in white text.
28 Brabners 3 Z7 A1580

What’s at stake in an HMRC investigation?

HMRC is a formidable opponent that enjoys wide-ranging powers. It can take many years to finally reach a resolution, resulting in increased stress and financial pressures. 

In addition to tax liabilities, there are wider repercussions including potential imprisonment, reputational damage, loss of business, associated regulatory investigations, director disqualification, liquidation and bankruptcy (with HMRC being the petitioning creditor in approximately half of all liquidations and one fifth of bankruptcies).

Get in touch
The Times Best Law Firms 2027

Brabners’ financial crime and fraud team has seen increased instructions for corporate internal investigations and matters involving Financial Conduct Authority-regulated businesses, complementing its work across financial crime, compliance and risk management.

Liverpool office reception

Experts in all types of tax dispute

Our lawyers have extensive experience of both civil and criminal tax disputes, having acted in some of the largest and most complicated disputes of recent years.

We work with individuals, SMEs and large corporations and have a strong network of specialist barristers, accountants and tax advisers to assist where needed. 

Our approach is to work closely and collaboratively with every client to understand their immediate and long-term concerns and find tailored and innovative options to conclude matters as efficiently and cost-effectively as possible. 

HMRC investigations can lead to both civil and criminal actions against taxpayers. Its preference in most cases will be to take the civil route through the First Tier Tax Tribunal, where it must only prove its case on the civil standard of proof — the balance of probabilities — rather than the criminal standard of ‘beyond reasonable doubt’. However, in cases that involve allegations of serious and organised tax evasion, HMRC has the power to take the criminal route.

Call our experts
Dan Stower

Specialist tax dispute lawyers

Our Head of Corporate Defence and Compliance, Dan Stowers, has 27 years’ experience in the criminal defence of corporates and individuals in respect of serious and complex matters. His extensive experience includes the defence of fraud in cases brought by a number of different law enforcement and regulatory bodies including those prosecuted by HMRC for matters such as VAT fraud including Missing Trader Intra-Community fraud, income tax fraud and fraud in relation to the Construction Industry Scheme. 

Dan is also an Accredited Counter Fraud Specialist who regularly assists clients in conducting corporate internal investigations in relation to financial misconduct including those involving potential tax irregularities. Where appropriate, Dan will guide clients through the self-reporting process. Dan’s extensive criminal fraud defence experience enables him to conduct internal corporate investigations and advise corporates on their financial crime compliance processes.

Meet the team

Our tax dispute and investigation services

Work highlights — civil cases

Appeals against assessments and personal penalties

Acting on behalf of a businessman in respect of six successful appeals against assessments and personal penalties exceeding £25m made by HMRC, alleging VAT and duty evasion. This involved a three-month trial involving 50 witnesses and over 100,000 documents as well as three separate criminal prosecutions pursued by HMRC for tax-related offences. HMRC has appealed to the Upper Tribunal, in which we have also been instructed.

Worldwide freezing order

Acting on behalf of a client subject to a worldwide freezing order obtained by HMRC nine years ago and securing multiple variations to this in order to alleviate some of the hardship caused by the order.

Construction Industry Scheme liability

Acting on behalf of a construction company in appeals to the First-Tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) against HMRC’s determinations in respect of £5.5m in Construction Industry Scheme liability, together with an application for judicial review of HMRC’s interpretation and application of the relevant regulations.

Allegations of MTIC fraud

Acting in appeals against HMRC’s decisions to revoke a company client’s VAT number and refuse its right to deduct input tax due to allegations of MTIC fraud involving scrap metal, leading to assessments and penalties being raised by HMRC of circa £4m. In addition, HMRC has issued Officer’s Liability Notices to current and former officers of the company, which it has also been necessary to appeal.

Alleged fraudulent evasion of VAT and Excise Duty

Acting in appeals concerning revocation by HMRC of a company client’s AWRS approval and multiple assessments and penalties in relation to the alleged fraudulent evasion of VAT and Excise Duty of circa £1.5m. HMRC has issued Officer’s Liability Notices to those involved in the company, which have also been appealed.

Allegations of MTIC fraud involving alcohol

Acting for a corporate client in appeals against HMRC’s refusal of its right to deduct input tax due to allegations of MTIC fraud involving alcohol, following failed criminal prosecutions by HMRC of individuals involved with the company.

Challenge to Final Closure Notices

Assisting an individual client with a challenge to Final Closure Notices issued by HMRC and alleged liabilities arising from Self-Assessment tax returns, where the parties’ respective positions are circa £1.2m apart.

Appeals against VAT surcharges

Acting for two corporate clients in respect of consolidated appeals against multiple VAT surcharges imposed by HMRC, following late payment of VAT as a result of technical errors encountered with HMRC’s system.

Dealings with HMRC

Acted for an international brewer in respect of its dealings with HMRC, compliance programme and due diligence undertaken on its supply chain.

Work highlights — criminal cases

Furnishing false invoices

Acted for a haulier prosecuted for furnishing false invoices in respect of non-existent deliveries used to offset VAT liabilities of £1.5m. Achieved an intermittent custody sentence and negotiated a reduced confiscation payment with the Revenue and Customs Prosecution Service.

Prosecuted for failing to charge VAT

Acted for a broker of industrial machinery supplied through the UK and Germany who was prosecuted for failing to charge VAT on parts supplies in order to gain a competitive advantage. Achieved a suspended sentence and limited confiscation order.

Missing Trader Intra Community Fraud

Acted for the director of a telecoms company prosecuted for multi-million-pound Missing Trader Intra Community Fraud and associated Proceeds of Crime Act application.

Insights from our litigation experts

Tax dispute & investigation FAQs

A blonde-haired older person in a turquoise shirt sits facing the camera in a café, with a server and tables softly blurred in the background.

Brabners Personal

From protecting your professional life and relationships to planning for the future and dealing with the unexpected, Brabners Personal brings together the expertise that you need to navigate any challenge.

We're here for every chapter

We’re here to

Make the difference

Trusted guidance is just a call, email or message away. With hundreds of nationally recognised experts, get in touch today to find out how we can help.

Loading form...

Send an enquiry